In connection with these types of loans, the Underwoods in addition to purchased two policies out of borrowing from the bank life insurance coverage off First Franklin and you may Voyager

In connection with these types of loans, the Underwoods in addition to purchased two policies out of borrowing from the bank life insurance coverage off First Franklin and you may Voyager

Decided: August 01, 1997

Debra Underwood is attractive regarding an overview wisdom joined in favor of First Franklin Financial Firm (“Very first Franklin”), Voyager Term life insurance Team (“Voyager”), and you will Joe Seals, a member of staff away from Basic Franklin. This example is moved to so it judge by finest courtroom, pursuant to § 12-2-7(6), Ala.Code 1975.

Inside December 1992 plus April 1993, Debra Underwood along with her spouse, Jesse Underwood, borrowed funds from First Franklin. In case there is a passing, the financing coverage create shell out completely your debt owed so you can Earliest Franklin.

Inside November 1993, this new Underwoods filed a voluntary petition to possess Chapter thirteen bankruptcy defense, number within petition certain bills, such as the a couple of funds with Earliest Franklin. Jesse Underwood passed away in the December 1994, while the Underwoods remained in bankruptcy proceeding. Brand new personal bankruptcy package try confirmed towards January eight, 1994.

Into the January thirteen, 1995, Ms. Underwood filed a state with Earliest Franklin to the borrowing existence insurance policies arises from both Voyager formula. Towards January twenty six, 1995, Voyager issued a couple of monitors so you can First Franklin, investing positives about level of $1,808, to be applied to your Ms. Underwood’s loans that have Earliest Monetary. Ms. Underwood unearthed that the 2 formula had paid down a sum much lower than the total amount who provides satisfied their loan harmony which have Basic Franklin. She telephoned Seals, a buddy who had been plus an employee of Earliest have a glance at the weblink Franklin, to ascertain as to the reasons the financing life insurance coverage continues did not shell out in full their financing obligations which have Earliest Franklin. Seals advised Ms. Underwood you to she had been given the continues she was entitled to discovered since the she and her husband got recorded having case of bankruptcy during the November 1993. Seals further endangered so you’re able to repossess the girl auto, given that borrowing life insurance had not fully reduced the financing.


To the March twenty-two, 1995, Ms. Underwood registered a software to own a difficulty personal bankruptcy release, centered on their partner’s passing. The girl application are supplied of the case of bankruptcy court into April 17, 1995. The fresh bankruptcy trustee is discharged on may twenty two, 1995, in addition to Chapter 13 continuing is closed.

To your January dos, 1996, Ms. Underwood recorded this against First Franklin, Voyager, and you can Seals, saying claims alleging swindle, violation off offer, and you may crappy believe, all of the relating to the professionals paid off from the Voyager around this lady insurance coverage regulations. Earliest Franklin, Voyager, and you will Seals moved having an overview view, arguing your “doctrine away from judicial estoppel” banned Ms. Underwood of seeking the lady claims. This new demonstration judge supplied new activity and you may registered a wisdom when you look at the choose of one’s defendants.

A motion getting conclusion view is generally provided when there is no genuine issue of matter fact as well as the swinging people is eligible to a judgment because a matter of law. Hinkle v. Burgreen Employing Co., 678 Very.2d 797 (Ala.Civ.App.1996). If your swinging class helps make a prima facie demonstrating one zero genuine problem of question truth can be found and this are titled so you’re able to a wisdom once the a matter of legislation, the burden shifts into the nonmovant commit submit with research undertaking a real problem of point fact. Id. So you’re able to defeat a properly supported summary wisdom action, brand new nonmovant need to expose generous research carrying out a bona-fide problem of thing fact. Id.

A borrower during the a case of bankruptcy must reveal people legal actions probably to appear in an effective nonbankruptcy perspective. Luna v. Rule Bank from Middle Tennessee, Inc., 631 Very.2d 917 (Ala.1993). This new doctrine away from judicial estoppel pertains to prevent a celebration regarding and if a position during the a legal proceeding contradictory which have a posture in past times asserted. Id. Thus, the fresh doctrine prevents a borrower exactly who don’t reveal a declare inside a bankruptcy from asserting the brand new claim for the a beneficial nonbankruptcy function.

Leave a Comment